Breakdown Analysis of When You Are Old The poem is comprised of three stanzas, each containing four lines. Articles not indexed electronically, so the print version of journal must be consulted. Most readers come to Yeats through his poetry, but he saw his work for the stage as equal to if not greater than his poetic enterprise. Includes basic chronology of life and work. We hope that The Imaginative Conservative answers T. In the second stanza, the speaker is still omniscient, however the tone along with the rhythm changes a great deal.
Clearly she is beautiful and he loves her so I see no reason why he should try and make this work. Sponsor 122 Free Video Tutorials Please I make on youtube such as. While re-reading, she should recall how many people loved her for both true and false reasons, namely because of her beauty. Literature has evolved and taken on new forms, becoming so accessible that it can be studied by a scholar to publish in a journal, or a high school or undergraduate student to post onto a blog. The rhyme scheme reflects this as well. And so each venture Is a new beginning, a raid on the inarticulate, With shabby equipment always deteriorating In the general mess of imprecision of feeling, Undisciplined squads of emotion. But, even without ending the sentence, he states in the following lines that the old, bald heads do not write their own poems.
We hope that this doesn't happen to us. The poem is unique in it's own way, as there a shift in it. I think that Yeats thereby makes a point that the study of literature can become so methodical, it removes the emotion originally bound to the text. Regarded as the leading journal for Yeats criticism. He seems to mean that the famous love-poet Catullus was not such an absent-minded and stupid old man but a really original and creative man.
When one first reads this poem, it is hard to understand its meaning with out already knowing about Catullus and the situation that surrounded him. Some of the essayists in have also contributed to , which gives a more in-depth survey of major themes. Historical Context While Yeats did write political poems, this is not one of them. I would find by the edge of that water The collar-bone of a hare Worn thin by the lapping of water, And pierce it through with a gimlet, and stare At the old bitter world where they marry in churches, And laugh over the untroubled water At all who marry in churches, Through the white thin bone of a hare. Here, instead of having the second and fourth verses rhyme, it's the first and third. In the second phrase of the first line, we see that the bald heads are not heads themselves but real and complete persons. All shuffle there, all cough in ink; All wear the carpet with their shoes; All think what other people think; All know the man their neighbour knows.
On the contrary; the poet is an artist. Tone: The poem follows a structure and in itself is a poem about structure. The young poets, he says, actually feel the pains and sorrows of love; they toss on their beds and write their poems in the actually felt despair of love. Besides a few metaphoric expressions, the whole poem is an angry assault upon the age-old prestige and respect of 'old' scholars. The speaker has very specific instructions for his lover. The speaker of the poem is speaking in a manner that sounds like an angry and insulting description of the old scholars; it even sounds as if he is disputing with someone who has been telling him that the old scholars really have the merits of true learning and experience, creativity and imagination. Basically, here Yeats is asking the scholars if they actually agree with what they had written, and if their translation or commentary would not have been different had it not been influenced by the rest of the scholars.
You can see it from the first line, to the very end. In fact, it is not uncommon for old people to be under such an illusion. The speaker thinks that everyone has a certain common type of thoughts and not everything makes poetry; this suggests that the old poet write just about anything in their confidence that they are experiencing and that they are respected by everyone. In the final stanza, the speaker tells his former lover that she should remember that this love did not last, and she should be filled with regret because of it. Lord, what would they say Did their Catullus walk that way? In fact the disgust and disrespect towards them is a bit too much - it goes to the extent that most readers would criticize. Bald heads forgetful of their sins, Old, learned, respectable bald heads Edit and annotate the lines That young men, tossing on their beds, Rhymed out in love's despair To flatter beauty's ignorant ear. This woman is probably Maud Gonne, an Irish revolutionary who ended up marrying another man.
The speaker suddenly exclaims in wonder; he wonders what the old men would think if they knew the poverty of their thoughts and feelings, or rather the fact that their so-called wisdom, creativity and originality are nothing but their own illusions supported by the world's false respect. Comprehensive volume divided into seven parts: Times, Places, Personalities, Themes, Philosophies, Arts, and Reception. But The Scholars reminds us that the greatest literary theorist cannot necessarily write a poem, and the greatest poets need not by any means be academics. Catullus and his mistranslations and misinterpretations is a metaphor for the possible interpretations of Yeats' work by the scholars. The poem is irritably disrespectful towards the old scholars whom we have all learnt to respect out of a conventional custom and habit thereof.
It is also understandable that he must have been criticized by older poets and scholars that his poetry is not matured; usually the lack of regard for the young and growing genius by the older men breeds this kind of anger in the young. F Lines 1 and 3 are an eye rhyme, it looks like it should rhyme but it actually doesn't. Posted on 2011-12-31 by a guest Post your Analysis Message This may only be an analysis of the writing. He finds the old so-called scholars lazy and unoriginal, forgetful and silly, and commonplace. Yeats proposed to her numerous times, and each time he was denied. The first stanza is the more bland of the two. Introduction provides concise overview of major themes in the drama: ritual, magic, the mask, the idea of tragedy, and the relationship of image, symbol, and style.
All shuffle there; all cough in ink; All wear the carpet with their shoes; All think what other people think; All know the man their neighbour knows. Providing a baseline and idea of what is quality writing, it has to be done continuously so as to keep up with the evolution of the medium. A Guide to the Prose Fiction of W. Maybe we have found a new literary device? Chronological analysis of short stories and novels John Sherman and The Speckled Bird written between 1887 and 1905. But this question is also very likely a rhetorical one.